Menu
Springs are pivotal in a vehicle’s suspension system, influencing factors such as load capacity, ride comfort, durability, cost, and applicability. Understanding these differences is crucial for informed decision-making, whether you’re a manufacturing plant or a wholesaler. Tailor your choices to your unique needs and priorities for optimal results.
3. Comparison Between Leaf Springs and Coil Springs
Leaf springs are a common suspension component in vehicles. They consist of several metal plates stacked together to form an arc shape. When the vehicle passes over bumps, the metal plates are flattened to absorb the impact. After the bump, the plates bounce back into shape due to their elasticity.
Leaf springs have several important parameters. Their length ranges from just a couple feet on small vehicles to over 5 feet on heavy trailer-s. Thickness can vary from 3-5mm for cars to 10-15mm for heavy vehicles. The plates are commonly made from alloy steels for strength and durability.
Leaf springs offer some advantages in suspension design. First, they have a simple and robust construction. The stacked metal plates are strong enough to support heavy vehicle weight. Leaf springs also cost less to manufacture than other suspension types. However, leaf springs also come with some drawbacks.
The ride in leaf-spring vehicles tends to be bumpy with significant vibration. This is because the stiffness of the stacked plates cannot absorb impacts as effectively. Metal fatigue can set in over time, causing the springs to permanently lose their shape and sag. Leaf springs can also contribute to sliding during hard braking or turning, as they allow more unspring vehicle weight.
Overall, leaf springs are simple and durable but compromise on ride comfort. They are best for heavy commercial vehicles where extreme loads outweigh ride quality factors. For passenger cars, other suspension types now prevail.
Coil springs work on the principle of torsion. They are made of steel wire looped in a spiral shape. When the vehicle hits a bump, the spring compresses. The tension of the coiled steel wire produces a rebound force to absorb the impact.
Key parameters of coil springs include the diameter or thickness of the spring steel wire. This can range from 4mm for small cars up to 12mm for heavy vehicles. The number of coils is also important, typically between 4 to 8. More coils allow more compression for absorbing shocks. Coil springs are made from tempered steel alloys to handle repetitive stress.
Coil springs offer superior ride comfort compared to leaf springs. Their spiral shape compresses and rebounds smoothly to cushion bumps. This results in less vibration being transmitted to the chassis. Coil springs are also lightweight and have a long fatigue life if made from quality steel.
However, coil springs do have some downsides. Their load capacity is lower, making them unsuitable for very heavy vehicles. Producing coil springs requires complex winding machines and heat treatment processes, so cost is higher. The ends of the coil also need to be precision ground to sit properly in mounts.
Overall, coil springs excel at providing a smooth, comfortable ride. Their flexing action isolates the car body from road shocks well. While more expensive, coil springs are ideal for passenger cars where ride quality matters. But leaf springs still prevail in heavy commercial vehicles.
There are some key differences between leaf springs and coil springs:
In terms of load capacity, leaf springs can support much higher weights. Their stacked steel plates are inherently stronger than the wire of a coil spring. Leaf springs are often rated for several tons of load capacity.
For ride comfort, coil springs provide superior shock absorption and isolation from bumps. Their spiral shape allows more gradual compression and rebound movement than the planar leaf springs. This results in a smoother ride.
Leaf springs allow more undesirable chassis movement from acceleration or turning forces. Their longitudinal mounting can allow some axle wind-up. Coil springs maintain proper wheel alignment better under dynamic loads.
Leaf springs tend to be used on heavy duty vehicles like trucks and commercial vans where load capacity is the priority. Coil springs are preferable for passenger cars and SUVs where ride comfort takes priority.
Finally, manufacturing cost is lower for leaf springs due to their simple stacked plate design. Coil springs require complex winding and heat treatment, so they are more expensive to produce.
By understanding these key differences, vehicle owners and engineers can select the best spring type based on their design priorities and needs. Load hauling calls for leaf springs, while passengers favor coils.
When selecting between leaf springs and coil springs, the vehicle type and usage are key considerations:
For heavy duty commercial vehicles like trucks and vans, leaf springs are the better choice. Their high load capacity and durability suit vehicles carrying heavy cargo or towing. Weight ratings of several tons are possible with properly designed leaf springs.
For regular passenger vehicles like cars and SUVs, coil springs optimize the riding experience. Their smooth compression absorbs bumps and provides superior isolation from road shocks. The lightweight and flexibility of coil springs also aid handling and braking control.
For performance vehicles where ride and handling are paramount, coilover suspensions allow full customization. Coilovers integrate the coil spring and shock absorber for independent wheel control. Ride height, stiffness, rebound rate and more can be tuned for track performance.
So in essence, heavy hauling calls for leaf springs, passengers favor coils, and serious performance demands coilovers. By matching the spring type to the vehicle duty and priorities, optimal suspensions can be designed. Manufacturers and savvy owners select springs based on the intended vehicle purpose and needs.
We’ve delved into the key differences between leaf springs and coil springs, equipping you with valuable insights to make informed procurement decisions. Whether you’re in the business of trailer, agricultural machinery, or commercial vehicle parts, TOW-MAX , with 15 years of industry expertise, stands ready to support your needs comprehensively. For further inquiries or to initiate your procurement, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us:
Phone：86-574-8786-2718
Email: [email protected]
We look forward to establishing a long-term partnership with you, providing top-notch trailer parts and professional assistance. Thank you for choosing Tow-Max as your trusted parts supplier.
Our trailer parts expert will answer your inquiries within 12 hours.
Tow-Max is a trusted supplier of trailer parts in China, known for its huge variety of products and one-stop services. We have been supplying customers from Australia, South America, the USA, and the Middle East. Our business partners are located in Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide, Mexico City, Dubai, etc.
No.163-1, Shang yang Road, Dongqian Lake Industrial Zone, Ningbo, 315121, Zhejiang, China
+86-574-8786-2718
+86-574-8786-2717
sales(at)soaringtrailerparts.com
©Copyright 2020. Tow-Max. All rights reserved. Powered by MML.
